Perfume Review – Ormonde Jayne Tolu: A Perfect, Lovely Paradox

Paradox: (noun) A seemingly absurb or self-contradictory statement that, when investigated, may well prove to be true. Tolu, from the luxe niche London house of OJ ToluOrmonde Jayne, is a paradox in the most mesmerizing way possible. It is an airy, breezy, narcotically heady, heavy, dewy green, freshly orange floral… no, I mean, lushly spicy amberous oriental, no, I mean, a woody, balsam and pine smoky floriental…  It is a contradiction that delights, that keeps your nose plastered to your arm, that awes you with its heady, airy opulence, and that recalls the happiest moments of carefree youth while making you feel every inch a sophisticated adult. It is intoxicating. And I cannot recommend it enough.

Linda Pilkington, founder of Ormande Jayne.

Linda Pilkington, founder of Ormonde Jayne.

Ormonde Jayne is a high-end, niche London perfume house founded by Linda Pilkington in 2002. She sounds like a fascinating woman. According to her biography on the website, her passion for perfumery began early, as a teenager, and this “led Linda to her first career, growing and selling flowers by the roadside outside her Cheshire family home. She also learnt to make scented candles and bathing oils from craft sets and courses, and created beautiful scented cushions for birthday and Christmas presents.” After years spent travelling and exploring the world, working in places from South America, Africa and the Far East, soy bean farms to ice cream parlours, she returned to London where she began making her own perfumes. She showed her creations at a London trade show where she won repeatedly. And then she was asked to make “the perfect, scented candle” for Chanel itself. After that, in 2002, she opened her own boutique and her perfumes have received praise ever since, including a number of 5- and 4-star reviews from Luca Turin.

Ormonde Jayne’s philosophy is simple:

one of quality and true luxury, the pursuit of beauty and elegance. Our perfume library reposes on an exquisitely simple principle – extraordinarily beautiful scents using speciality oils not widely used in the perfume industry today.

Her goal is to return

to the golden age of perfumery, an elegant era when fragrance creation was a fine art, when essential oils and absolutes were allowed to infuse for a period of months before filtration and then allowed to mature again before bottling, resulting in a deeper, more complex perfume.

Honestly, I cannot recall the last time I was so impressed with a niche house upon my very first sniff, and I plan to investigate her whole line, sample by sample. My first exposure to Frederic Malle, Serge Lutens, Amouage, L’Artisan, Tom Ford, By Kilian, Caron, Montale, and a whole host of other lines never resulted in anything like this. My reactions to those houses varied from indifference to ambivalence, from liking to loving (but not feeling utterly compelled to buy), to truly not understanding what all the fuss was about. Ormonde Jayne is different. It’s not simply that Tolu was bewitching, but that the perfume smells unbelievably luxurious and rich in that genuinely old-school, classique manner of the haute French perfume houses of yesteryear. THIS is what perfumes used to be, almost across the board, and what they are so rarely today.

This is class. It is class, purity, and luxury made simple but, yet, also made fresh and modern at the same time. It’s like smelling the vintage version of some great classic, but made even better. No wonder Luca Turin seems to think that Ormonde Jayne is beating Caron and Guerlain at their own game. I hadn’t believed him when I read that statement a while back and, in truth, I don’t always agree with Mr. Turin, but dammit, he’s absolutely correct in this instance. “Tolu is the kind of fragrance Guerlain or Caron would be turning out regularly if all was right in the world[.]”

If I ever met Ms. Pilkington, I would hug her for returning some of my wide-eyed innocence and belief, after feeling far too long jaded, cynical and oh so depressed at the current state of perfumes in this IFRA-infected world. I would also hug her for her blunt statement in a 2010 interview with the Perfume Shrine that she will never reformulate her perfumes, allergies be damned! “No, we haven’t reformulated anything. I never will. Nor discontinue any in our fragrance rotation. We have 12 fragrances now and I absolutely love each and every one of them. I don’t want to make any changes!” When asked what she would say to a customer asking about allergic reactions, her response was:

I say “If you think madame that it might be give you any risk of an allergic reaction, it would be best if you didn’t buy this perfume”. We talk over some of the ingredients (if the customer knows about any specific trigger or if we think there might be some) and I say “just don’t buy it”. In the end, I don’t give a f*ck if they buy or not, as long as we’re stand our ground and do not mislead. *laughing*

Fascinating as Ms. Pilkington is, nothing is more so than Tolu. I’m hard-pressed not to summarize my entire review in one word: heaven! But, in an attempt to make you understand why I am so thrilled (and why I had to keep stopping writing to sniff my arms), let me tell you more about the scent itself. According to Fragrantica (where it has nary a single bad review), Tolu is classified as a Woody Oriental. (I think there should be a new category entitled “Perfect Paradox.”) It is technically a woman’s eau de parfum, though I think a man could pull this off, especially during the dry-down.

Ormonde Jayne’s website states:

Perfume treasure, this opulent velvety formulation with pure Tolu resin [a Peruvian tree resin] takes you on a sensual Oriental journey. Laced with golden frankincense and amber, the scent’s core is enveloped with a heady mix of orange blossom and clary sage, while intense citrus notes consolidate the harmony.

Top Notes: Juniper berry, orange blossom and clary sage
Heart Notes: Orchid, Moroccan rose and muguet [lily-of-the-valley]
Base Notes: Tolu, tonka bean, golden frankincense and amber.

You know those word association games? I put on Tolu and the very first word that shoots across my brain is “Enchanting!” In fact, that is the first thing I jotted down. There is warm, billowing blanket of orange blossom which immediately rolls onto thenerolifruitandflowersb skin. It’s not screechy, sharp and overpoweringly cloying like Tom Ford‘s Neroli Portofino, nor is it overly sweet like many synthetic orange scents. It’s also not light and imperceptible like the orange in a few niche perfumes. It’s heady in a soft way, and is one of the brightest, freshest orange blossom scents I’ve smelled in a long time. The sillage is also powerful, which makes me ecstatic as, far too often for my liking, orange blossom is merely a faint hint amongst many supporting notes. Not here. It is the star, stage center, with the brightest lights shining on it.


Mimosa in the South of France.

I must confess at the outset that I have a monumental weakness for orange blossom that supercedes many other ingredients or notes that I love. And the orange blossom here reminds me strongly of the oils or essences used in my favorite body cream, Couvent de Minimes Orange Blossom. Here, as there, there is a purity to the scent that makes it clear that real oils were used in the product. It calls to mind my childhood in Cannes with visits to Provence; I am immediately transported back to my old home at the end of Spring. Summer is around the corner, and there is a vast sea of orange trees in bloom along side golden mimosas bushes swaying in the wind under blue skies that are neither hazy with heat nor pale eggshell blue from the winter. The orange is intoxicating, narcotic and, yet, so airy at the same time that it feels like fizzy champagne in an odd way. It’s been only 15 minutes and, yet, I ponder currency exchanges in my head and whether my bank account can afford an immediate purchase, while the sane part of my brain pleads to wait out the full development of the perfume before acting rashly.


Juniper berries.

Thirty minutes in, a faintly smoky warmth starts to creep in. Amber that is rich, almost nutty, and with a faint hint of smoke from incense. Oddly, the scent on one arm is very different from that on the other where I smell no amber at all but, rather, crisp pine needles and balsam. It must come from the juniper berries listed in the top notes, and it is fresh, bright and rich — as if plucked just moments before from living trees growing on the high reaches of the snowy Alps. Clearly, some extremely expensive oils must have been used because at no time does it smell sharp, synthetic, or like the common air-freshener sort of pine in some perfumes. On both arms, the orange blossoms seem to have receded momentarily, as if to make way for the fresh, woody pines and amber, but it is just for a moment. The orange blossom is not only the quietly solid foundation upon which other notes rest, but a permanent part of this opening stage.

Soon, the juniper recedes and the flowers return. As always, there is the rich top head of orange blossom but there are other accompanying notes, too, even if they are but supporting players on the stage. There is also orchid and lily-of-the-valley. Orchid is a hard scent to describe, or even to classify, as it can smell of a variety of different things, depending on type. To me, white orchids can sometimes evoke the light purple impression of lilac and hyacinth, but in an oddly earthy way. That is the way the orchid seems to smell here. Lily-of-the-valley (or muguet) smells somewhat similar to my nose, bouquet-de-muguetwithout the earthy richness. The Perfume Shrine describes lily-of-the-valley as follows:

Lily of the valley is technically a green floral with rosy-lemony nuance [which] … has been adequately used in classical fragrances as a catalyst to “open up” and freshen the bouquet of the other floral essences in the heart, much like we allow fresh air to come in contact with an uncorked red wine to let it “breathe” and bring out its best.

To me, however, lily-of-the-valley is a light, fresh floral note that smells almost like a green, lilac-hyacinth hybrid. Here, it counters the headiness of the orange blossom with freshness that is dewy and ethereally light. It is almost sheer, and yet, it has depth and richness. The note makes Tolu, in these very early stages, call to mind the delicacy of Dior‘s Diorissimo, a very lily-of-the-valley scent.

Thus far, Tolu has leaned far more towards a floral scent than an oriental, let alone a spicy woody one. There are amber notes which flicker back and forth, but, for the first two hours, I have the reverse experience of what some people report. I don’t get spice right off the bat at all. There is the Diorissimo resemblance from the lily-of-the-valley, along with some rose and the hyacinth-like notes of orchid. And all of this is within the warm haze of orange blossom. The latter is something which projects outwards, while the other scents are closer to the skin, almost as if they were inside a big, airy, orange coccoon.

I can now smell the clary sage, but never think that it is the same sort of sage that you use in cooking. According to a helpful discussion on Basenotes, clary sage is nothing like regular (Dalmatian) sage that you have in your herb rack. It is sweeter, fresher and with a hint of peppermint, while Dalmatian sage is more bitter, biting and aromatic. Clary sage is also said to have elements of lavender in its odor profile and, sometimes, even of green tea. Here, it adds to the impression of freshness and lightness in Tolu, while also adding a faintly minty, sweet note that cuts through some of the richness of the orange blossom. It’s almost as if a faintly minty lavender note has joined those orange blossoms and dewy, green flowers, but it’s so light that I wonder if I imagine it at times.

That lightness, along with much of the airiness in Tolu, brings me to one of the perfume’s several lovely contradictions. It is airy and light, while narcotically heady and heavy. I realise that I’m not making much sense. It is the ultimate example of a paradox and really requires that you test out this scent yourself to understand it. The best way I can explain it is that there are two polar opposite groups of scents here. The first is the dewy, fresh, green, spring-like notes: lily-of-the-valley; white orchid; lavender-y and minty clary sage; and then, lilac and hyacinth (though they are not listed as ingredients, their smell is there to me). It flashes colours of white, lavender, soft lilac and bright green, all in a soft, airy light of the dawn’s first dew. The second competing group is the scent of just one thing: orange blossoms. Narcotically heavy, almost inducing an obsessive inability to resist sniffing my arm, triggering an utter delirium of joy amidst the flashing colours of bright orange at the heart of noon. It is a paradox, yes, but it is also a sign of a masterful hand. I contemplate why I only smelled Tolu after Christmas, and not before when it would have been at the very top of my wish list.

An hour in, rich vanilla starts to appear. It’s creamy, not powdery, and smells faintly like a rich, banana custard. It almost makes me think of ylang-ylang but there is no such ingredient in Tolu. Some people on Fragrantica have referenced an oriental milky rice note, but I think the accord is far richer and heavier than the light sort of milky rice note I associate with scents like Kenzo‘s Amour line. I think the issue here is the combination of tonka bean and tolu balsam. Tonka bean smells of vanilla, while tolu balsam is a tree resin. Unlike benzoin, another resin, tolu balsam has a nutty, sometimes almond-like accord to accompany its vanilla and cinnamon heart. (You can read more about tolu balsam and other resins in the Glossary.) It has a greater richness and depth than the often powdery benzoin accord.

Soon, tolu balsam’s soft, lush, warm vanilla notes are joined by spice and smoke. I smell rich frankincense, but it is not peppery or dirty. The vanilla from the tonka bean and its accompanying powder notes soften the blunt edges of the frankincense, turning the latter into a light swirl of black smoke, rather than a heavy darkness. The rich resins and the myrrh create an impression of caramel and amber, but touched with a woody pine accord.

Three hours in, and all the way to the end of its dry-down at hour seven, Tolu is all incense, vanilla, honeyed amber and caramel, with a hint of pine. The subtle smoke and incense are gorgeous, as is the surprising earthiness that contradicts the velvety softness underlying the sweet scent. That said, for me, the dry-down never really progresses much beyond the panoply of resinous notes. It’s lovely, rich and soft, but I preferred those hypnotic opening and middle notes. (It’s hardly surprising given my passion for orange blossom.)

All in all, this is an utterly luxurious, captivating scent. It doesn’t perform twists of complexity, doesn’t have suddenly crazy notes popping in at a random stage, doesn’t try to shock you with something edgily disturbing, and doesn’t do anything other than the promise Ormonde Jayne made at the outset: “one of quality and true luxury, the pursuit of beauty and elegance.” It is a perfume that I have to have. It is a scent that will make me join the legion of admirers on Fragrantica who repeat “gorgeous,” “sophisticated,” and “classy” like a broken record. It smells of wealth and luxury; the sunny South of France interposed with the pine-covered snowy Alps of Gstaad, and the smoke of the Orient. It is a paradox wrapped in opulence, but it enchants you from the very first whiff. And it is utterly perfect.

Sillage & Longevity: Enormous sillage for the first three hours, then closer to the skin. However, on others, the projection is reported to last even longer. As for longevity, it was quite good, though as always you have to keep in mind that my body consumes perfume. On me, I could smell traces of it on my arm seven hours after putting it on. It was soft, but it was there. On others, the longevity is reported to be enormous.
Cost & Availability: The fragrance is available in perfume extract (30%) and eau de parfum (25%) in 50 ml flacon. Tolu is available at the Ormonde Jayne store in London, at Harrods in London, Fortum & Mason, or on Ormonde Jayne’s website. It is not sold in any department stores in the U.S. The website offers purchases in USD currency and, until January 14th, 2013, all shipping is complimentary with a hand-poured candle is offered as a free gift. The website’s page for purchases in US dollar lists the costs of Tolu as follows: a 1.7 oz/50 ml bottle of eau de parfum costs $126, while the pure parfum comes in a 1.7 oz/50 ml “premium French flacon with a gold OJ motif stopper and Japanese ribbons” and costs $300. There is a set of travel sized purse sprays (4 x 10ml) that costs $100 and a Discovery set of all 12 fragrances in 2 ml mini-sprays for $75. The latter is described as follows: “Ormonde Jayne’s Discovery Set is comprised of 12 x 2ml mini sprays of eau de parfum, together with a brochure explaining each perfume, all housed in a black and gold box… and whats more, the shipping is complimentary worldwide.” Tolu is also available in different bath, lotion, cream and candle forms. Harrods sells a 50 ml/1.7 oz bottle of Tolu for £80.00. Ormonde Jayne fragrances are also sold in Brussels, Belgium at Senteurs d’Ailleurs and at Osswald in Zurich, Switzerland.
Samples: You can also order samples of Tolu from various sample sites. The one I use, Surrender to Chance, sells samples starting at $3.99 for half of the standard 1 ml vial. Surrender to Chance ships worldwide for about $5.95 (though it’s a little bit more for larger orders over $75), and for $2.95 for all orders within the U.S., regardless of the size of the order.

34 thoughts on “Perfume Review – Ormonde Jayne Tolu: A Perfect, Lovely Paradox

    • Thank you so much, Steve! And how lovely to see you here. 😀 It was very sweet of you to stop by. One of these days, I will review a cologne that may be just the perfect one for you and tempt you away from your Burberry! xoxox

  1. Better than Couvent de Minimes? Oh dear! (I trust you fully, it’s my wallet that is expressing dismay.)

  2. Pingback: Beauty Tutorials » Sunday Link Love, Volume #124

  3. Ormonde Jayne is one of my favorite brands: there isn’t a single perfume in the main line that I dislike. Tolu is a nice one on me but definitely not my favorite from the line. I bought a travel spray of it last year but haven’t even finished yet the sample I had before. But who knows – maybe I’l change my mind when I wear it next time.

    • Undina, what are some of your favorites or, if you can pick just one, your all-time favorite? I have Woman and Orris Noir but I haven’t smelled or tried either one yet. (I don’t smell things at all until I’m about to review them so that I can focus and so that I don’t get any preconceived notions from lack of sufficient attention.) Did any of the ones you love lead you into making a full bottle purchase? 🙂

      • My absolute favorite is Ta’if. I had a couple of decants and now I’ve just bought one travel spray of it. It would have been a full bottle already but I’m considering the parfum concentration purchase and since it’s so expensive I thought I might do it when I travel to London the next time.

        My second favorite is Tiare followed by Orris Noir – for both of them I have a travel spray. I also like Ormonde Woman (have a decant) and Champaca (partial bottle). My vSO just got Ormonde Man travel spray as a gift from me for the New Year. The rest of them will just stay on the samples phase. At least for now.

  4. This sounds like something I would love! Orange blossom, rose, vanilla. I think I’ll order the sampler of 12; I’m really curious about her perfumes (I have a friend who only wears OJ and she RAVES about it all the time).

    • This perfume is made for you! I think I may have mentioned it to Kace before he left, though I cannot be sure now. I know I wanted to because this is definitely something that has your name all over it. This and maybe also the Tom Ford Noir de Noir, a very rich, damask, almost meaty, Henry VIII-like rose. But this one absolutely. Does your friend have a particular O/J favorite? Let me know if you end up ordering the sample box of 12.

  5. Kafka! Ormonde Jayne is quoting your blog on their Facebook profile! Big congrats! That’s a sing of appreciation. I once had similar situation with M.Micallef when I reviewed Style

    • Whoa!!!!!! How lovely! The funny thing is that I’ve been preparing a review of Ormonde Woman. I would have posted it yesterday but I decided I need to do some editing so I didn’t post a 4,000 word treatise on the perfume. My posts are long enough as it is without my rapture adding to their length! 😀 Thank you so much for letting me know, Lucas. I’m FB friends with them but haven’t had time to check FB today.

      • Yes, that’s definitely lovely. Situations like that are a great reward for perfume bloggers. I have not much experience with OJ, would have to got to London to smell some.
        Wow 4,000 words, you seriously got a lot to say!

        • I average around 2,200 words I think, maybe 2,500 so I’m wordy in general! LOL. Ormonde Woman is a magnificent scent and, you know, very unisex in spite of its name. I wish it were easier to get a hold of the perfumes, since there is no store in America either. At least we have the decant/sample sites, though; I wish Poland had something similar so you could try things more easily. 🙁

          • Well, there’s one decanting site in Poland but their prices are tremendously high and they don’t offer anything I couldn’t get myself.

          • Ah, well, if the prices are ridiculous, then it’s the same as not being an option or available at all. Hopefully, Ormonde Jayne will notice and maybe send you some samples to try. Their perfumes are of magnificent quality and I’ve fallen for them incredibly hard. They may be my favorite brand out of all the niche ones that I’ve tried thus far.

  6. Pingback: Perfume Review – Ormonde Woman by Ormonde Jayne: The Dream Landscape | Kafkaesque

  7. Pingback: Sunday Link Love, Volume #124 | FFBlogs

  8. Pingback: Celebrating #100 | Kafkaesque

  9. Pingback: Perfume Review: Tsarina by Ormonde Jayne (Four Corners of the Earth Collection) | Kafkaesque

  10. I just love Ormonde Jayne and I love Linda Pilkington. It’s so funny reading your reviews and saying, “OMG. That’s just what I said.” This time it was your bewitching comment. But what is even stranger is that I said it about the first OJ I tried, which wasn’t even Tolu, it was Man! And I remember thinking at that time, what is it about this that is so bewitching? And Man is certainly very similar to Woman, and even to the base of Orris Noir, but not seemingly like Tolu, or is it? What spell does Linda weave throughout her line? It is just lovely. And each is lovely in its own way. Now, I’m not in love with them all, but that has to be put in the context of the ones I LOVE so much that if they don’t reach that level, it is simply the high bar the others set. And I can’t rank them, but my list includes: Man, Woman, Orris Noir, Ta’if, Tolu, Isfarkand. Quality ingredients? Yes, ma’am. Example? Well, take the oakmoss in Isfarkand for instance. I am just not an oakmoss fan. And in most examples I find it so off-putting, so uninteresting, just boring if not dry and repulsive. Now, in Isfarkand oakmoss has been redefined for me. It is what all oakmoss should be: refined, elegant, debonaire. And that is just a fraction of Isfarkand. I have the Discovery set and a full bottle of Man, but I will get more. Isn’t it a shame that OJ is not more accessible? And this strange “Dangerous Goods” penalty for shipping is really such a crime. I must say though that OJ will take a huge chunk out of the $90 per 50 ml charge if multiple bottles are ordered. By my calculations they absorb essentially $200 of the “Dangerous Goods” charge if 3 bottles are ordered just for example. How awesome is that? And the 4x10ml travel sizes come in at the same per ml charge as the 50 ml bottles but completely avoids the “Dangerous Goods” penalty due to their size. Yes, I should be a SA for OJ and if Linda reads this, I simply say, “Call me and let’s figure out how to get this line in more American hands.”

    And I spritzed a little Tolu again after reading your review and it is so wonderful. Paradise! The word derives from garden or park, Jannah in Arabic, paridayda in Old Persian, and what a lovely garden that would be 🙂

    • I love Tolu, Cohibadad! And I really should try more of the line, but my issues with ISO E Super that is in many (many!) of the fragrances have held me back. It is the note that I like the least in all the world, and it’s in the base of most O/Js, unfortunately. That said, I’ve been planning to get to Ormonde Man, Isfarkand and Ta’if for a while, but something brand new always sems to come up. I will do so eventually. 🙂

      • OJ is challenging. After gushing over Woman yesterday I did two small spritzes and completely knocked out my tastebuds. The other day I blew out my nose on Puredistance M, and now I blew out my tastebuds on Woman. What a week. Everything had this almost tar-smeared taste. The Hemlock? So I would say Linda walks a fine line with her creations. On one side of the line it is glorious and on the other side it can be sickening. And I have learned how certain fragrances can be dangerous before dinner. I had never experienced that before. But I still love them with moderation 🙂

          • I don’t think so. If Molecule 01 is ISO E Super, I have no problem smelling it and I find it quite nice. Cedary ozone is probably how I would describe it?

          • Actually, I just tested it and it does seem that if I get more than just a little of this stuff it seems to make me feel a little sick and slightly effect my taste. That is just with one spritz and a few whiffs. I think two spritzes would make me feel very sick. Quite a risky ingredient. It reminds me a lot of what is in Hermes Voyage.

          • Interesting. You may want to read my long article on ISO E Super, and see some of the fragrances listed which contain it. Perhaps, one day, you can conduct a few more tests in terms of assessing the quantity and amount that you can handle. There is a lot of ISO E Super in Ormonde Jayne’s Zizan, for example, though it’s in most of her fragrances to some degree or another. For me, a heavy dose of ISO E Super can give me a brief headache, but I’m still luckier than some who get raging migraines without fail from the note. And it’s in bloody *everything* it seems, at times. At least you just get peppery ozone; I get pure rubbing alcohol and medicinal antiseptic 9 times out of 10. 🙁

  11. OMG!!!! After all your suggestions for orange blossoms and for do-able ambers, and having tried so so many of both types, THIS is the one!!!!!!!!! I can’t get over it: a 2 in 1. I have been slowly going through Ormonde’s 12 sample set. I kept expecting to like one of the white florals, and although very well crafted, none really grabbed me. I have to say that I am more of a woody-oriental-comfort or rose type so I shouldn’t be surprised. I enjoyed Orris Noir far more than I should, given that any iris-powder heads me towards the grape seed oil to scrub it off. I might even consider a decant. Last on the list were Ta’if – lovely. And if I hadn’t already splurged on Mohur Extrait, it would have been a must-have. and finally, Tolu. yes yes yes. Full bottle. finally. the one (in two). Of orange blossoms with the trees, of amber that doesn’t smother, of sophistication and loveliness, of sillage and discretion. MUST have.
    Thank you for all the suggestions in between, Kafka. I had a great time with George’s coffee& tobacco (no orange blossom on me) and not liking at all but loving the learning of the ambergris in Ambre Aurea (which you did anticipate to be my reaction). Just to name a few.
    Tolu: Heaven indeed

    • Ah, Tolu. I’m so glad you found something that fits exactly what you were looking for on both an orange blossom and an amber front. I have to confess, I forgot completely about Tolu when we were talking about orange blossom scents earlier. If I am to be very frank, I’ve mentally blocked Tolu out since the time of my review. A month or so after I wrote it, I tried Ormonde Jayne’s Montabaco, and it wouldn’t be an exaggeration to say that it broke my nose. The amount of ISO E Super in that one is so dramatically significant that it essentially over-sensitized my nose for life, resulting in an acute sensitivity to the aromachemical that has made *all* fragrances with ISO E Supercrappy difficult for me to test.

      It also completely ruined Tolu for me. I have a full bottle, and can’t go near it. The ISO E gives me a profound headache, so I now also avoid all the other O/J scents as well, since the perfumer (Geza Schoen) is famous for his obsession with ISO E Super, and sticks whopping amounts of it in all the things he creates for the brand. In your case, if you’re anosmic to ISO E Super and/or haven’t encountered much of it before Tolu, then I can completely see how you might interpret the scent solely a shimmering brightness. I did once myself. I hope you never experience so much of the note that you end up in my shoes, because Tolu is really lovely.

      In terms of the solid version, I haven’t tried it so I can’t comment but, generally speaking, in my experience, solids wear much closer to the skin because there is less alcohol and the base is different.

      • Sniff.
        Today was my all-out Tolu day. I had dabbed discreetly on my inner left wrist twice, and liked it so much I went all out with the almost end of my sample- my customary wear is inner elbows and sternal notch. And I was so happy I posted the comment. A few hours later I have a pounding headache. Is it the ISO-E?! Noooooo. I have read your post dedicated to the topic, and the Montabaco revulsion. Which is why it wasn’t one of my sampling choices. It may be that my headache is atmospheric. That always happens when the skies are heavy with rain but don’t let to. It builds and builds. Like today. But could it be the scent? I we save the last of my sample to try on a clear and cloudless day, before committing to a total purchase. We shall see. I have all year olfactory sensitivities so even if I don’t know what it smells like it could be ISO-E. I hope not.
        Anyways. It appears that your prediction of my enjoyment of resin-vanilla-esque tilted ambers is spot on, so I have scoured your site for vanilla recommendations. Never thought I was a vanilla girl but one never knows.
        Thanks for the ongoing dialogue.

        • I really hope you get to try it again on a day when the skies are not heavy with rain so that we can see what your ISO E Super sensitivity may be like. My suggestion if you’re still contemplating a blind buy is to wait and order a tiny 2 ml spray decant from Surrender to Chance. They ship to Canada for a reasonable amount. The key will be for you to experience Tolu when *sprayed,* as you would if you owned a full bottle, not dabbing “discretely” in tiny amounts. That’s not what you would do if you bought the fragrance. Spraying actually increases a fragrance’s reach and expands the volume cloud, so to speak, over dabbing. It would thereby amplify any suspect, problematic note like the ISO E Super. In my experience with Tolu, the ISO E Super felt even greater and more prominent when I sprayed from my bottle than when I applied from a dab sample vial.

Comments are closed.